Saturday, March 24, 2007

NEP in Crisis

Musa: Brief Umno on why it has to give up NEP

Musa Hitam wants Umno to have a special briefing to explain to its members why it was time to give up the New Economic Policy (NEP) for the success of the Iskandar Development Region (IDR). He said that there were already hundreds of Malays who had the capability to do business and on merit. Musa said, he realised that there was a need to have a change in mindset to draw investors to the country. In the last few decades of the NEP, the country used to have an Ali Baba way of doing business where Ali would give his name and Baba would do all the work. “As time went on, Ali and Baba became equal and Ali was able to deliver as much as Baba. Now, there are even Alis who are using the Babas not as sleeping partners but as equals,” he quipped. Musa also said that foreign investors who came to the country were not interested in the NEP, cronyism or nepotism as their primary focus was on making money. He suggested that instead of imposing conditional approvals, a more palatable method would be to provide potential foreign and local investors with a list of Malay entrepreneurs who were capable of doing business and leaving it the investors to decide. “The IDR is an opportunity to demonstrate that we have arrived and we are able to do this,” Musa said.

Ghani and Shahrir back move to drop Bumi quotas

Johor MB Abdul Ghani Othman said he agreed with the move to exempt IDR from policies that favour the bumiputras in a bid to attract investors. “IDR is a very defined area and there is enough bumiputra strength to participate in the development despite the FIC rules being relaxed completely,” Ghani said.

Johor Baru MP Datuk Shahrir Samad said the public should not be alarmed with the move. "People have the impression that everything requires a racial quota. It’s not exactly something new,” he said. “There are precedents. MSC-status companies are not required to have a racial quota.”

However, PM Pak Lah has this to say:




Ghani had always been against any move that intrude the NEP. Why did he want the rule to be relaxed? Was there a motive? Would it be an initial step to lure foreign investors in with their monies and then later cry foul? Would foreign investors believe us and can be confident that our rules have integrity and would not change in later days? If history is a guide, then history is bound to repeat itself.

It seems that when we need others badly, we would lower our criteria but when the need is fulfilled, then the criteria may revert to the old song sung blue.

5 comments:

Monsterball said...

Hi Maverick,
Its not a completely unprecedented move to give such relaxation in a limited, specified area. In the export manufacturing industry, many NEP requirements have been set aside or watered down to encourage foreign investment. This was a major factor in the growth of the industry in the 1990's. And the export manufacturing sector is probably the most efficient and meritrocratic part of the economy.

However, there's a lingering suspicion that the NEP requirements could be reimposed at any time as all the relevant regulations are still fully on the books. They just chose not to enforce them.
This is still a disincentive to some foreign investors in industries which have a long investment payback period.

Yes, I guess they are really hard up to get foreign investment in the IDR, that's why even the super racial supremacist Ghani is considering this.

I like the idea - if this helps the IDR succeed, it could serve as a beneficial "slippery slope" to support eventual phasing out of the NEP in the rest of the country.

Anonymous said...

This is exactly the name of your blog.

What assurance they can give foreign investors that they will be no change in the event Badawi not in power anymore?

Haven't they seen what happen when Mahathir step down?

Anonymous said...

To summarise all these:-

Shifting of goalposts during game time.

Anonymous said...

They know the problems, at least seem to know. Going by their usual pattern of ding-donging, nonsenses will continue and screwup will repeat.

Animals learn but idiots don't, do they?

Anonymous said...

this ghani...another true-blooded politician..say one thing before umno GA then now this....hypocrisy ...i thikn UMNO doesn't even have an ideology anymore except for make more money....!!!!