Hindraf's leaders - P.Uthayakumar, V. Ganabatirau, M. Manoharan, R. Kenghadharan, T. Vasantha Kumar and P. Waythamoorthy, can now smile and celebrate. Their programme had achieved the set objectives for which they had set out to do although the glory will go to MIC; but it doesn't matter as the Indians are the beneficiaries.
Deputy Prime Minister Najib Tun Razak had assured Indians that the government would now, after 50 years, finally, address 7 major issues faced by the Indian community. They are:
- Greater employment and promotion opportunities in the civil services;
- Better educational opportunities in public universities, especially in critical courses;
- More scholarships;
- Greater access to entrepreneurship training and micro-credit loans;
- Equitable participation in the share market;
- More effective urban poverty eradication programme; and
- Dedicated mechanism to monitor the public delivery services.
Though 5 of them are in detention camp at Kamunting, Taiping, and Waythamoorthy had to remain as a political refugee in a foreign country to evade arrest under the ISA.
All of them - including all those who were mistreated at the recent rally on 25th November 2007, plus all those who had participated to give the rally such an impact - they are the real effective champions of the Indian community because they ultimately cause the government to eat their pride and ego and forced to make promises which are illusory and imaginative.
All of them - including all those who were mistreated at the recent rally on 25th November 2007, plus all those who had participated to give the rally such an impact - they are the real effective champions of the Indian community because they ultimately cause the government to eat their pride and ego and forced to make promises which are illusory and imaginative.
If the government have such an intention to make good their defects, and want to show they had such intention, the first thing as of now, since it is election time, is affirmative actions, that is, to give more seats in parliament to MIC as a show of sincerity. MIC had only one Cabinet Minister for the past 2 decades.
But to do so, will be to sacrifice others in the BN. Who then would be sacrifice? MCA? No, because Najib and Pak Lah had made similar promises to the Chinese. Gerakan? No, because they too had only one Cabinet Minister.
So, who then? UMNO? That's the only likelihood if the PM and DPM are going to keep their words as promised, as good Muslims shall not lie.
Well, for a start, the promises comes with some conditions. Najib told the Indian community that MIC must re-engineer themselves to stay relevant.
What does this mean?
It must mean that MIC must win all the seats they had previously won to prove that they remain the main representative of the Indian community in this country.
What happen if MIC fails?
Well, lets say all Hindraf's leaders who contested won, they could effectively be considered the new voice and representatives of the Indian community even though they may be contesting only 5 seats.
Then what will happen? Well, UMNO will quietly invite the 5 to join Barisan and MIC becomes a yesterday entity, just like the PPP of SP Srinivasagam.
And the new 5 Indian heroes will champion the Indian causes? Yes and No! They will get the glory of rhetorics and they will be forced to make all sorts of promises which they can't keep as they do not have the effective voice to be heard. They eventually will be what MIC and PPP had been and become subdued, subordinated and submerged.
But will they? Will they forget their principles for which they fought for? Yes, because they will be made rich by the system and they will be riding on the same gravy train as was Samy and his cadre.
Then what? Then, the Indians will have to wait another 50 years, and by which time we will have a new Hindraf, maybe, another new groupings with another new name, such as Indraf, and they will be fighting for the same damn thing. It's call, History do repeat itself.
So, it seems UMNO is the loser this time around? It seems to be!
But will UMNO members get angry and vote for PAS? There is a likelihood if the Malays become disgusted.
Why should they? Because, traditionally, over the last 30 years or so, greater employment and promotion opportunities are only given to them and no others. 99% of the director-generals of public services are Malays; the similar scenarios can be seen in city hall, government-link companies, uniform services and diplomats. All Design-Built-Turnkey contracts are exclusive and only Bumiputera majority-owned contractors can participate, and all Class F contracts are exclusive for Bumiputeras.
So, if let say the PM and DPM are so damn sincere and intend to keep their promises this time around, who will be sacrifice to make way for the extra benefits of the Indians, for everything must sum up to 100%, and if Indians are given an extra 1%, it must come from someone, or from a creed who would have to sacrifice the 1%.
But we can't say the Malays are sacrificing the little? Ya, they are going to sacrifice the little of what they had taken from the others over the last 30 years.
Will it work? Yes and No!
Why? Because the promises are made for election time only and after election we have the UMNO general assembly which will be the time for calls to make changes to the previous status quo, and maybe, a little more of what they don't already have.
Like that also can ah? It has always been so, and will remain so.
But will the people believed it knowing the outcome had always been so? Well, they are fickle minded type and will remain as they always had been, which is why the top leaders dared to so many promises for which they know they need not keep. They also know that they can re-promise, promise to make further more promises, and reinvent past promises.
Are you sure that there is such thing called re-promise and re-invent promises? Ya, go read my news archives of all those promises in 2004, 2005, 2006 and 2007. There are just too many and I am not able to provide the link here. That's why my blog is named after the promisor of broken promise.
Can you just give some links of the articles? Ok lah! read these:
(1), (2), (3), (4), and (5)
So, who then? UMNO? That's the only likelihood if the PM and DPM are going to keep their words as promised, as good Muslims shall not lie.
Well, for a start, the promises comes with some conditions. Najib told the Indian community that MIC must re-engineer themselves to stay relevant.
What does this mean?
It must mean that MIC must win all the seats they had previously won to prove that they remain the main representative of the Indian community in this country.
What happen if MIC fails?
Well, lets say all Hindraf's leaders who contested won, they could effectively be considered the new voice and representatives of the Indian community even though they may be contesting only 5 seats.
Then what will happen? Well, UMNO will quietly invite the 5 to join Barisan and MIC becomes a yesterday entity, just like the PPP of SP Srinivasagam.
And the new 5 Indian heroes will champion the Indian causes? Yes and No! They will get the glory of rhetorics and they will be forced to make all sorts of promises which they can't keep as they do not have the effective voice to be heard. They eventually will be what MIC and PPP had been and become subdued, subordinated and submerged.
But will they? Will they forget their principles for which they fought for? Yes, because they will be made rich by the system and they will be riding on the same gravy train as was Samy and his cadre.
Then what? Then, the Indians will have to wait another 50 years, and by which time we will have a new Hindraf, maybe, another new groupings with another new name, such as Indraf, and they will be fighting for the same damn thing. It's call, History do repeat itself.
So, it seems UMNO is the loser this time around? It seems to be!
But will UMNO members get angry and vote for PAS? There is a likelihood if the Malays become disgusted.
Why should they? Because, traditionally, over the last 30 years or so, greater employment and promotion opportunities are only given to them and no others. 99% of the director-generals of public services are Malays; the similar scenarios can be seen in city hall, government-link companies, uniform services and diplomats. All Design-Built-Turnkey contracts are exclusive and only Bumiputera majority-owned contractors can participate, and all Class F contracts are exclusive for Bumiputeras.
So, if let say the PM and DPM are so damn sincere and intend to keep their promises this time around, who will be sacrifice to make way for the extra benefits of the Indians, for everything must sum up to 100%, and if Indians are given an extra 1%, it must come from someone, or from a creed who would have to sacrifice the 1%.
But we can't say the Malays are sacrificing the little? Ya, they are going to sacrifice the little of what they had taken from the others over the last 30 years.
Will it work? Yes and No!
Why? Because the promises are made for election time only and after election we have the UMNO general assembly which will be the time for calls to make changes to the previous status quo, and maybe, a little more of what they don't already have.
Like that also can ah? It has always been so, and will remain so.
But will the people believed it knowing the outcome had always been so? Well, they are fickle minded type and will remain as they always had been, which is why the top leaders dared to so many promises for which they know they need not keep. They also know that they can re-promise, promise to make further more promises, and reinvent past promises.
Are you sure that there is such thing called re-promise and re-invent promises? Ya, go read my news archives of all those promises in 2004, 2005, 2006 and 2007. There are just too many and I am not able to provide the link here. That's why my blog is named after the promisor of broken promise.
Can you just give some links of the articles? Ok lah! read these:
(1), (2), (3), (4), and (5)
19 comments:
Its time I think you start blogging about broken promises,.... put them all under one title.....lest we forget,......mudah lupa,....
Jefus,
There are just too many of them. I have linked some here and there're lots more in my archive. It will take me months to search though them.
I've never believed in racial discrimination. The whole thing about the Malays getting greater employment and promotion opportunities are just making them more lazy. Don't get me wrong, we do enjoy getting all those things, but when you look at the bigger picture, I am ashamed to admit that my race has become complacent and I think it's time the goverment do something about that. Besides, we are all Malaysians, aren't we? Why the discrimination?
no need to sacrifice lah maverick. just expand the alredi existing largest cabinet in the world. another GUINESS WORLD OF RECORD, no? what the heck, they anyway need more pygmy brains to come out with some ideas on how to govern fairly.
The sad thing is, despite all the cakap tak serupa bikin, the rakyat is still forgiving. Or maybe many are afraid to change.
All the races in Msia is afraid of changes except malay, while the malays doesn’t want to change!!
Those are the unsung Hero of the Indian community! But still they have a hard choice to make!
Vote for BN and hope for a better future "AS THEY PROMISE" or CHANGE CHANGE???
Hopeful,
There is no positive discrimination among the races. There is only discriminatory policies and conventions which is creatively improvised to suit the political reality.
The discriminatory acts are caused by the power-aspiring leaders and representatives from UMNO who tried to portray their Malay absolutism to project themselves as the Divine Protector of a single creed, for which, they want it to be seen that only they can protect the Malays from the evils of all other races.
In truth, what they want is plenty of wealth and wives, and servants and slaves, istana, helicoptor, all without the need to sweat, toil or work as they could use the NEP to get APs, projects to sell, state land, everything which is free of which they could then sell for huge profits and become billionaires.
Helen,
It's political reality!
Cruel Angel,
Thanks for participating in the discourse.
But I don't think the Malays doesn't want change. But the some Malays (particularly those from UMNO) have entrenched economic-phobias; they feared they couldn't compete based on pure merit with others and UMNO had pursued this weakness of the Malays for their own personal gains.
good point there mav... i think history will repeat itself... election time is near... there will be plenty of promises... but then again... i have a feeling your blog title will prevail... once again...
Zewt,
Foxes are plenty and it's foxtival time.
There are some “ifs” as mentioned by PM Abdullah in his comments:” if the government felt that the requests could be met or were appropriate for consideration, it would approve them” But will these goodies swayed back Indian votes to BN . It is most unlikely, even the release of the Hindraf 5 now would be of no use as the Indian Community is determined to use this GE 2008 to put Samy Vellu into political oblivion. This 1-day convention was an eleventh hour effort to stamp the tide of eroding support. More details at
Go H E R E
Nice one Mave.. I was perplexed reading all those words of yours. Damn!
In the brink of GE, I may copy something from you, which I think can brainwash those who think they are clever enough...
TQ
ex-sinarpurnama
Bumis-----RM3.7billon
Mca-----RM15million
Mic-----Public Holiday
Multidimid,
You are right; there's just too many "ifs".
Terang Bulan,
Are you still perplexed?
Psc,
That's a good one...hahahaha
the indians were promised those things last elections and the elections before..indians eem easy to kau tim..ijok was an example..for a sewing machine...they sold their vote and their soul.
Artchan,
You may be right; human are myopic and tend to take immediate gain.
In everyone's sustenance, at some dated, our inner throw goes out. It is then burst into enthusiasm beside an be faced with with another benign being. We should all be thankful for those people who rekindle the inner transport
In the whole world's existence, at some time, our inner pep goes out. It is then burst into zeal by an be faced with with another hominoid being. We should all be thankful for those people who rekindle the inner spirit
In everyone's existence, at some pass‚, our inner fire goes out. It is then bust into zeal beside an face with another magnanimous being. We should all be indebted for those people who rekindle the inner inspiration
Post a Comment